Thursday, July 31, 2014

Preparing for Change - Balancing Educational Excellence and Fiscal Responsibility

As the Benton CSD prepares for a new school year with great anticipation and excitement, we also face some challenges and decisions that will likely change the landscape of the school district in terms of grade level patterns in elementary buildings and schedule design at the MS/HS during the 2015-16 school year.  While we have weathered the fiscal realities of the district well for many years, we have reached a point where some level of change and restructuring will be required.  There are essentially three factors impacting the school district and making these discussions and planning necessary: 1) enrollment decline over time; 2) inadequate supplemental state aid and revenue support; and 3) general fund expenditures outpacing the current revenue sources.   As a result, it has been necessary for the school district to utilize the Unspent Authorized Budget (UAB) portion of the maximum budget for the district to pay for general fund expenditures for the past two years and likely again during the 2014-15 school year.  The UAB is the “rainy day” fund for the school district.  Iowa school districts operate on a controlled budget basis with the primary components for funding being the actual enrollment and the state per pupil funding.

Since the 2001-02 school year, the actual enrollment for the school district has dropped 272 students from 1768 to 1496 during the 2013-14 school year.  This represents a 15.4% enrollment decline over a 13 year period.  Based on enrollment projections for the year ahead, we anticipate that enrollment will continue to decline based on the size of the incoming kindergarten class in comparison to the senior class just graduated.   Despite the decline in enrollment, we have maintained a similar mode of operation as it relates to the PK-12 system for many years.   While the district has experienced enrollment decline, we have also seen inadequate levels of per pupil state funding for education in four of the past five years.  While the district experiences an annual per pupil increase of 4% from FY06 through FY10, the levels of funding during FY 11, 13, and 14 was just 2% with a zero percent level of funding in FY12.  This has certainly had a significant and negative impact on available revenues for general fund operations.

As we look to close our financial record for FY 14 it appears that general fund expenditures will approach $16 million.  This compares to actual expenditures in the previous year of $15,564,389. The Maximum Authorized Budget for FY14 was $18.5 Million compared to $19.6 Million in FY13.  As a result, the Unspent Authorized Budget will decrease from approximately $4 million at the close of FY 13 to $2.5 million at the close of FY14.  Any reduction in the UAB also has a direct impact on reducing the Maximum Authorized Budget for the school district.  It is imperative that the school district work at reversing the trend that has developed over the course of the past couple of years.  Due to the enrollment projections anticipated the only way to accomplish this goal of fiscal responsibility is through reducing general fund expenditures. 

During a Board Work Session on June 25th the administration presented the following plan for consideration in addressing both educational excellence and fiscal responsibility:

1.      PK-6 Elementary Centers from 4 attendance centers to 3 attendance centers with the following grade level configurations:

Ø  Atkins Center                 PK-3    Project Three Sections per grade level in K-3                                                        Demographic Boundaries to include Director Districts 1,3,4,5

Ø  Keystone Center            PK-3    Project Double Sections per grade level K-3            
Demographic Boundaries to include Director Districts 2,6,7

Ø  Norway Center               4-6       Project Four or Five Sections in grades 4-6 
 (All 4-6 grade students in district)

2.      7-12 Common Schedule:

Ø  Transition from a block schedule to a traditional schedule at the 9-12 level
Ø  Common schedule provides greater flexibility in terms of staff assignments and sectioning decisions.


The Board of Education will continue to discuss this important topic during the Fall of 2014.   A timeline for a decision will be established and an opportunity for public input will be available and communicated to district patrons prior to a final decision being made by the Board.   In addition, a link will be made available on the Benton website for parents and patrons to access the data and information to be used in decision making and action planning.  This is obviously a very important decision for the school community as we plan for the future of Benton Community.